A chiller's nameplate efficiency is measured at full load, but a real plant is at full load for only a few hours a year. What you pay for is part-load performance, and that depends heavily on which machines are running together.
Part-load efficiency and IPLV
IPLV (integrated part-load value) is a single efficiency figure that weights four load points. Under AHRI Standard 550/590 the weights are 1% at 100% load, 42% at 75%, 45% at 50% and 12% at 25%. In other words, the standard itself assumes a chiller spends almost all of its life below full load.
Each chiller has a sweet spot
- Constant-speed chillers are usually most efficient at high load.
- Variable-speed chillers are usually most efficient at mid load, especially with cool condenser water.
- Below about 30% load, most chillers become inefficient and less stable.
What good staging looks like
- Start and stop chillers based on load and efficiency, not only on supply temperature alarms.
- Run the combination that meets the load with the lowest total plant power, including pumps and tower fans.
- Avoid running two chillers lightly loaded when one would carry the load comfortably, unless they are variable-speed machines that are better at mid load.
- Use delays and minimum run times to prevent short cycling.
- Rotate duty to balance run hours, without overriding efficiency.
Common staging mistakes
- An extra chiller started for flow because of low delta-T, not for load.
- Fixed schedules that ignore weather and occupancy.
- Operators keeping a "safety" chiller on all day.
- Mixed old and new chillers staged as if they were identical.
Why automation helps
The best combination changes hour by hour with load, wet-bulb temperature and each machine's condition. A plant management system that models every chiller can make that decision continuously. This is the core job of our CPMS, and its results are verified monthly against the agreed baseline.